Honest opinion Chris.
Design the site yourself the old one looks much better and is easy to navigate. Ready made template sites just don't cut it mate.
In my humble opinion the new site is too cluttered and to be honest it looks like an online shop especially with the ads.
I know you're doing this in your spare time bud and trust me it's really appreciated by everybody (even if you don't support the right team
) I personally would be quite happy to throw some money your way (be it in the way of beers or whatever) or help with the hosting costs and I'm pretty sure everybody else would be happy to help in their own way.
I would much rather see something clean, easy to navigate and something which obviously states clearly who we are and what we are about.
I personally hate fixed width sites (though that is very much a personal opinion) and would rather see frames (yes old fashioned I know but they work so why mess with them
) for easy navigation.
Just my two pence (you're gonna be sorry you asked
)